UK Pet Forums Forum banner

Should we get another dog, after re-homing our previous?

3K views 39 replies 30 participants last post by  Alexisb  
#1 ·
Honest and helpful opinions welcomed please! LONG POST, BEWARE!

Here's our situation, myself and my husband bought a Springer Spaniel from a first-time hobby breeder (first mistake), 6 years ago. We were childless at the time, we did the research, Denver came from Working stock, with Field Trial Champions as his lineage and from Rytex/Badgercourt stock with a 5-generation pedigree and Hip Scored parents. He was a lovely, cheeky puppy who loved people. We took to dog owning like a couple of pro's (I'd longed for a dog as long as I can remember, and my husband grew up with Springers). Denver went to puppy socialisation classes, I did obedience and gun dog training with him, he came to the office where we all worked and was walked 4-6 times a day. He came on holidays with us and all seemed well for the first 6 months, before disaster struck. Denver became suddenly, completely blind in both eyes (I now know it was PRA), and that was the start of our demise...

Despite being advised by 2 vets to put him down, over the next 2.5 years we tried to help Denver with his condition. I did specialist training with a Police Dog Trainer, to learn new commands for blind dogs and help Denver not bump into everything. We 'scent-marked' the house and never moved furniture around. It didn't always work, Denver was constantly running headlong into things, drawing blood, hurting his head and scratching his corneas and he eventually became fearful of other dogs, new places and things. Family daytrips or holidays with the dog were now impossible, ordinary walks around the neighbourhood or parks were frought with obstacles and danger. He was by now a large (above average for a springer), strong and willful dog, and despite my best efforts to train him to walk on the lead, he often toppled over the pram and once pulled my shoulder out, requiring physio treatment. We moved house from a quiet culdesac (with a postage stamp for a garden) to a much bigger house with huge garden, but on a main road. We thought Denver would prefer the space outside, and he did (he hated being inside the house now, and fought us when we tried to bring him in) but I also think he found the new noises very frightening and would bark so much that we had a letter from the Council about noise pollution. We also had a toddler by this time, who was beginning to walk and would occasionally surprise Denver by touching him when he wasn't expecting it - Denver 'corrected' our little boy 3 times (drawing blood) before we started to consider he may need re-homing. He went from an outgoing and inquisitve puppy, to a fearful and anxious dog. It was absolutely heartbreaking to watch.

Finally we took the agonising decision to rehome him with NESSR, who were brilliant, non-judgemental and found him a loving forever home with an older, childless couple, who had another female Springer (would help Denver around the place) and lived on a farm in rural Wales. I believe in my heart Denver is happy where he is now, as he doesn't have to contend with the noise of a built up area or with young children.

3 years on, and we still think about the dog-shaped hole that this experience has left in our life. We never imagined we would re-home Denver - he was supposed to be the start of our family life together, and I know that our lives will not be complete without a furry friend to share it with. Now we have a 5 year old boy and a 2.5 year old girl, and 2 rescue guinea pigs who (although sweet in their own way) are not the same as having dogs! I am tentatively considering the possibility that we may be ready for another dog. I am a full time stay at home mum, we are an active family (I cycle the kids to nursery/pre-school every day) and there are so many parks and walks in the area that would be ideal to raise a dog in.

I have researched long and hard on breeds which are most suitable to family life, and recognise now that a Springer's from working stock would not have been an ideal choice in the first place. I have come to rest upon the Cockapoo (American specifically), for their characteristics, size, and good health (compared to pure breeds) and have started to research reputable breeders who do the right health testing.

My question is, given our history and experience, do people think we should have another attempt at owning another dog??
 
#2 ·
Hi, welcome to pf.

It's not just irresponsible owners that give their dogs away, it all depends on individual circumstances. Why not get another dog? You seem very aware of the pros and cons and I think choosing a different type is a good idea.
There is a lot of arguing on here about the rights and wrongs of cross breeding so be aware :D

My sister has a labradoodle - fantastic dog, and I have met loads of cockerpoos, they seem like great family pets.
 
#3 ·
I would say go for it, you sound like a perfect owner! There is nothing wrong with rehoming a dog when you have done your best but the dog would clearly be better in a different environment. ;)
 
#5 ·
I can't see why not. Although you rehomed a very troubled dog, you did everything you could to make his life with you work.

A cockerpoo could be a good choice. Be careful about health tests in both parents and particularly the temperament of the cocker parent, as cockers can be possessive - not good with a small child in the house.
 
#7 ·
I would say yes why not. You rehomed your last dog for his benefit and made sure he went to a good home with another dog and a much quieter home which is better for a blind dog. T he only thing i would say is make sure both parents of the cockerpoo has been eye tested as both breeds have heriditary eye problems. There is somone on here that runs a web site for cockerpoos that has loads of reallt good information someone clever will be along with the link i'm useless at such things
 
#8 ·
After reading everything, you sound like a good dog owner. You moved him into a better situation for him and your child.

Sometimes even good people have to rehome dogs because circumstances change.

Well done and I say go for it :)

Via cockerpoos, speak with the cockerpoo club they can help you out. Cockerpoolover on here runs the club and i'm sure can help you out.
 
#9 ·
After reading everything, you sound like a good dog owner. You moved him into a better situation for him and your child.

Sometimes even good people have to rehome dogs because circumstances change.

Well done and I say go for it :)

Via cockerpoos, speak with the cockerpoo club they can help you out. Cockerpoolover on here runs the club and i'm sure can help you out.
I was just about to say this ^^^^^

I'll jsut add the link to make this not look like a waste of a post :D

Cockapoos Owners Club Home page
 
#11 ·
Rehoming a dog isn't always a bad thing to do and it sounds like you rehomed yours for the right reasons, not just because you couldn't be bothered with him. I don't see why you shouldn't get another dog just because you rehomed one who wasn't at all suitable for reasons beyond your control.
 
#12 · (Edited)
I have come to rest upon the Cockapoo (American specifically), for their characteristics, size, and good health (compared to pure breeds)
If you are going to get a Cockapoo or any other crossbreed, please do not believe this myth. It's simply not true and if you've told this by a breeder then you've been misled. My knowledge about crossbreed health and genetics is very limited but put simply; because both Poodles and Cockers can suffer from luxating patella, hip dysplasia, epilepsy and PRA, any puppies from a poodle x cocker mating can potentially inherit these conditions.

There are a couple of users on this forum who are passionate about the crossbreed, and may be able to help you find a breeder. Both their user names escape me atm, but hopefully someone will come along and steer you in the right direction :)

eta the user on here is Cockerpoo Lover - I should have put two and two together ;)
 
#13 ·
Hi and welcome to PF. From reading your post you were a fabulous and responsible owner to Denver....sadly these things do happen and bite us on the bum ( I had to make the decision to PTS my 2 yr old dobe due to a brain tumour that was making her quality of life not great and she was being unpredictable)

You obviously have been doing research into different breeds and I would say go for it. Any dog would really have fell on their feet coming to live with you
 
#15 ·
You didn't 'give up' on Denver, you gave him a 2nd chance where others would have had him pts, I can't honestly think of anything else you could have done that would have been better for him. Definitely did the right thing with him.

I think you and your family should do some research on good breeders (I am sure there will be people on here who can help) and get yourself a puppy :)
 
#16 ·
It sounds to me that you were absolutely dedicated to doing the best for Denver (going far further than many people would) and I'm sure you will for another dog. Welcome to PF.
 
#18 ·
you had a tough time with Denver and did your best for him, that's all anyone can expect... good luck with your new pup but would emphasise what others have said, that the 'vigour' of the cross breed is a myth and parents should have all the health tests just as same breed parents should be...

with any cross there are variations, for me the factor with cockerpoos is that they can make the most loud and scary (to my Rosie anyway!) noise.... but then spaniels and poodles are loud so it's no wonder.. they can be gorgeous dogs so good luck with finding a breeder who health tests.

I'm sure that you'll be checking that both parents are PRA free, it was something a three way cross advertised as 'healthy cross breed pups' was found in the litter :-(
 
#19 ·
It sounds to me like you did everything you could, and in the end it was nothing that you did to make it all go so very wrong you were just victims of circumstances and re-homed for the good of the dog, and sounds like it was the right thing as he was so much happier and coped so much better.

I would go for it, You are obviously commited and ware willing to put the work in with training and everything, you are at home ideal for a puppy that needs ongoing care. The only thing that I would say is that puppies can somtimes nip and mouth, and having very young kids who run around and get exciteable it can also make a pup exciteable and mis behave too.

However having said this, you both know dogs well and how to train and have experience, so with management and training it shouldnt be a problem to get the blance right from the start of kids/dogs.
 
#20 ·
I'd say yes to a dog, no to a puppy.

As you know, pups do nip, bite and knock over children and if this is unacceptable to you then go for an older dog.

Besides that, wouldn't it be poetic for you to give a rescue dog their forever home after having to rehome your own dog? I say rescue also because you sound like a dedicated owner whose patient enough to work through any problems a rescue may have.
 
#22 · (Edited)
My only query is your choice of 'breed'.

There is NOTHING remotely healthier about getting a crossbreed, which is what a 'cockerpoo' is. It is a Cocker Spaniel X Poodle and as such, you could end up with a dog who has the 'weaker' characteristics/health problems of BOTH BREEDS.

Personally, I would look at either going to a really good breeder, by which I mean a genuine breeder producing pure breeds. Or, getting a rescue; there are many lovely and loving dogs just waiting for caring new homes.
 
#23 ·
OP Please feel free to look at our website. Lots of information on there and please feel free to join our club...membership is free. Details on my signature.


Some of the PF members are members of our FB and website and they don't even own a cockapoo but support our efforts in getting the right info out there.

But be warned they are very addictive dogs....we have lots now getting no 2 and 3......
 
#25 ·
My only query is your choice of 'breed'.

There is NOTHING remotely healthier about getting a crossbreed, which is what a 'cockerpoo' is. It is a Cocker Spaniel X Poodle and as such, you could end up with a dog who has the 'weaker' characteristics/health problems of BOTH BREEDS.

Personally, I would look at either going to a really good breeder, by which I mean a genuine breeder producing pure breeds. Or, getting a rescue; there are many lovely and loving dogs just waiting for caring new homes.
Your advice if going to a really good breeder is spot in and that is as important when getting a Cockapoo as it is a pedigree dog. Unfortunately in dog breeding there are unscrupulous people and you need to be on your guard when choosing where to get your puppy from.

Despite some comments believe it or not there are breeders of Cockapoo's who do health tests, will provide DNA evidence of PRA results etc and as has been mentioned in previous posts the Cockapoo Owners Club has bags of information on just this topic.

It is also full of people who have found good reputable breeders who sell healthy pups and give a lifelong guarantee of care for their dogs.

I would recommend to the OP that rather than just listen to people who go down the 'buy a pedigree or get a rescue' route as if the pedigree breeding industry doesn't have problems of its own, do your research, ask the right people and get your information from people who have experience with these dogs. You will then be able to make your decision based on knowledge, not prejudice.
 
#26 ·
Hiya i would say go for it.. i have an 11 week old cockapoo and if you do the right research despite what a lot of people say there ARE breeders who health test..

my zeldas parents were health tested and i have the test paper proof, she was a hobby breeder and she weaned the puppies onto raw which i think shows a good breeder as well, many use a cheap kibble.

Just be patient and do your research sure there is a puppy out there for you, and cockapoos are very sweet but seriously manic!!!!