UK Pet Forums Forum banner
61 - 80 of 86 Posts
I wouldn't give a dog a mars bar or anything to do with chocolate. Uneducated vet by the sounds of it badically advising he poisons his poor dog.
oh dear, but of course someone that comes on pet forums is bound to be better educated and have far more knowledge than a vet. I spoke to my vet once about chocolate and she said they have to eat a massive amount to do any harm.

My dog regularly has chocolate. Just never remotely enough to cause a problem. It's good to share :)
ditto, though I do not eat chocolate much now. My collie and standard poodle nicked a whole big box of Thorntons. I was dreadfully upset but the dogs were very happy. Can you still get those doggy chocolate buttons, I remember giving them to my dog when I was young. I know they are safe for dogs.

My husband used to get low sugar episodes and a mars bar put him right very quickly.

I think there is a lot of hysteria about a lot of things on here and people need to chill and enter the real world just to have a reality check periodically.
 
There's a big difference in the amount of sugar in a dog treat compared to a mars bar though Dan. If a dog is hypoglycaemic, they need a huge sugar boost IMMEDIATELY or they might die.
I'd guess it's probably impossible to get them to eat enough treats, especially if they're unconscious, whereas a piece of mars bar gives an instant sugar boost as it's melting in their mouth.
Diabetics aren't advised to eat Mars bars either, but if their sugar levels drop too low, it's one of the best things they can eat to keep them alive.
Being diabetic, my son never touches anything with sugar in it, like ice cream, chocolate, cake, sweets or puddings BUT he always keeps a Mars Bar handy in case his blood sugar level drops suddenly which it can and does.do, if he's been doing something particularly strenuous.
 
My last dog was PTS whilst eating a Mars Bar.

And of course someone actually let the words "chocolate is toxic to dogs" leave their lips when I told them before actually engaging brain...................... :)

But there is a lot of that about.:)
My last dog was PTS eating kinder chocolate - she loved it :D
 
Human chocolate isn't on this list for no reason. http://www.petforums.co.uk/threads/poisonous-items-for-dogs-this-could-save-you-dogs-life.22846/ Just a little reminder. Seen too many dogs on tv and in real life rushed to the vets because in real life owners thought chocolate wouldn't do any harm if their dogs were given a little bit. How wrong those owners were. I have seen one person round here giving their dog dairy milk chocolate, one of the bigger bars quite happily so I politely warned her about the fact with human chocolate and dogs. I saw said lady again and she had some dog treats with her, never gave her dog human chocolate again.
 
Human chocolate isn't on this list for no reason. http://www.petforums.co.uk/threads/poisonous-items-for-dogs-this-could-save-you-dogs-life.22846/ Just a little reminder. Seen too many dogs on tv and in real life rushed to the vets because in real life owners thought chocolate wouldn't do any harm if their dogs were given a little bit. How wrong those owners were. I have seen one person round here giving their dog dairy milk chocolate, one of the bigger bars quite happily so I politely warned her about the fact with human chocolate and dogs. I saw said lady again and she had some dog treats with her, never gave her dog human chocolate again.
If you had seen me giving my dog M&M pieces and told me about how dangerous chocolate is for dogs, I would have smiled politely to you, thanked you for the "information" and gone about my business, continuing to feed my dogs the occasional chocolate. I'm non confrontational that way :)

I'm glad people know that chocolate isn't the best thing to feed their dogs, but like so many things, it's not an absolute and context matters.
My great dane with an iron gut eating 5 M&Ms or a recees peanut butter cup is not going to do anything to her. A tiny chihuahua with a sensitive tummy and/or allergies eating an entire recees peanut butter cup is a totally different story.
 
Discussion starter · #69 ·
If you had seen me giving my dog M&M pieces and told me about how dangerous chocolate is for dogs, I would have smiled politely to you, thanked you for the "information" and gone about my business, continuing to feed my dogs the occasional chocolate. I'm non confrontational that way :)

I'm glad people know that chocolate isn't the best thing to feed their dogs, but like so many things, it's not an absolute and context matters.
My great dane with an iron gut eating 5 M&Ms or a recees peanut butter cup is not going to do anything to her. A tiny chihuahua with a sensitive tummy and/or allergies eating an entire recees peanut butter cup is a totally different story.
I'm still in shock that you give Reece's to the dogs. That is food that was delivered from the Gods and needs to go straight into your mouth!
 
Oh Reeces are amazing!! But even a tiny dog like Muttly 6.5kgs, would need to eat nearly half of one of those big 120g bars of Milk choccy to be ill. (Dark choccy is a totally different story)
 
Human chocolate isn't on this list for no reason. http://www.petforums.co.uk/threads/poisonous-items-for-dogs-this-could-save-you-dogs-life.22846/ Just a little reminder. Seen too many dogs on tv and in real life rushed to the vets because in real life owners thought chocolate wouldn't do any harm if their dogs were given a little bit. How wrong those owners were. I have seen one person round here giving their dog dairy milk chocolate, one of the bigger bars quite happily so I politely warned her about the fact with human chocolate and dogs. I saw said lady again and she had some dog treats with her, never gave her dog human chocolate again.
How on earth would you know what anyone was giving their dog unless they were shouting "here Fido, have another piece of dairy milk" o_O

I see people give their dogs treats all the time, I've never once noticed what type of food it is. It's in their hand and then it's down the dogs throat. If you were close enough to me to be able to read the brand name of the food I'm feeding my dog, I'd be telling you to back off and give me space.

Nobody is saying it's a great idea to feed dogs chocolate regularly. We all know that a lot of chocolate can be harmful. But when it comes to the choice of a dog dying from hypoglycaemia or a dog not dying from hypoglycaemia because it was given a piece of Mars bar, I know which I'd choose!

No matter how much you want to argue about it, a dog with a possible upset tummy is still better than a dead dog.
 
I'm still in shock that you give Reece's to the dogs. That is food that was delivered from the Gods and needs to go straight into your mouth!
Do they have reeces pieces there? Those things are awful and go straight to the dogs. Don't know that they have much/any chocolate in them though.
I do like the PB cups, but only in small doses, can't eat that many at once, too sweet, make my teeth sweat :D
 
... Seen too many dogs on tv and in real life rushed to the vets because in real life owners thought chocolate wouldn't do any harm if their dogs were given a little bit. How wrong those owners were.
How many have you seen in real life? I work at a vet surgery and we've had more cases of car keys swallowed than suspected chocolate poisoning. And tennis and rubber balls top the list of cases needing life saving treatment, as do garments such as socks. We've even had a pair of very fancy, jewel embellished ladies' thongs retrieved from the bowels of a dog. :p
 
Human chocolate isn't on this list for no reason. http://www.petforums.co.uk/threads/poisonous-items-for-dogs-this-could-save-you-dogs-life.22846/ Just a little reminder. Seen too many dogs on tv and in real life rushed to the vets because in real life owners thought chocolate wouldn't do any harm if their dogs were given a little bit. How wrong those owners were. I have seen one person round here giving their dog dairy milk chocolate, one of the bigger bars quite happily so I politely warned her about the fact with human chocolate and dogs. I saw said lady again and she had some dog treats with her, never gave her dog human chocolate again.
Human chocolate isn't on this list for no reason. http://www.petforums.co.uk/threads/poisonous-items-for-dogs-this-could-save-you-dogs-life.22846/ Just a little reminder. Seen too many dogs on tv and in real life rushed to the vets because in real life owners thought chocolate wouldn't do any harm if their dogs were given a little bit. How wrong those owners were. I have seen one person round here giving their dog dairy milk chocolate, one of the bigger bars quite happily so I politely warned her about the fact with human chocolate and dogs. I saw said lady again and she had some dog treats with her, never gave her dog human chocolate again.
Wow.

So you personally have seen "too many dogs" rushed to the Vet after being given chocolate?

Do you make a point of hanging around the Vet's Office, or peering through the windows of chocolate feeding dog owners?
 
I've had dogs for decades, worked for a vet, never seen a one rushed to the vet because of chocolate.
Raisins? Yup.
Xylitol? Yup.
Fatty chicken skin causing an acute attack of pancreatitis? Yup.
Chocolate? Never. And that's including our childhood terrier (small dog), who ate an entire box of Whitman's sampler's with some 60 pieces in it. He threw up, but was otherwise perfectly fine. Lived to be 18...
 
Discussion starter · #77 ·
Do they have reeces pieces there? Those things are awful and go straight to the dogs. Don't know that they have much/any chocolate in them though.
I do like the PB cups, but only in small doses, can't eat that many at once, too sweet, make my teeth sweat :D
I'm sure they do, but I've never tried them as I love the cups too much. My favourite ice cream is B&J Peanut Butter Cup. Oh man, that is to die for!
 
I'd definitely consider taking mars bars or milky way on a walk if my dogs had issues with blood sugar.
One of my friends gives tablets to their dogs when needed inside little milky ways or mars bars, like the one's you get in celebrations chocolates.
My Rottie had half a big chocolate bar once when it was left on the side and was left unsupervised - before we knew how capable he was of getting up on high tops..
Nothing ever came of it, I don't think he was even sick.
We did also check the amount of chocolate there was against his weight and it was way below what could be toxic, so never took him to the vets and just kept an eye on him for a few days and absolutely no side effects.
With mars bars and milky ways there is barely any chocolate on them so doubt it would even affect a small dog. I mean, always worth asking a vet or other owners which have experience with doing so... but overall I would do it.
 
61 - 80 of 86 Posts