He is still weary of her only does anything for me. Anyway took him out for his last toilet trip. Mum called him in calmly when we were near the door he backed away from her so I tried he came to me but when mum said good boy come on he backed away again. So what did mum do. Grabbed his collar then she pulled him in, she made him choke a bit. He ran straight to me and hid behind me poor boy. It scared him.