I've been working on recall this week with Bess. Now she is the quickest at picking things up than any dog I've ever had - which isn't always good, as it's the way she's learned a lot of bad behaviour. Anyway, this week I decided to really work on recall with the whistle. We did a session on Tuesday indoors - I used a three whistle signal, and she came running to me for a treat. I couldn't practice on Wednesday as I was at work all day and out training in the evening, so yesterday I picked it up again. This time I went straight in to see what she remembered. She was out in the garden pruning my vine (tried to tell her it's best done in December, but she obviously thinks she knows best) and out of sight of the back door. I stood at the back door, blew the whistle three times and she appeared running immediately! Everytime I let her out yesterday I did the same thing - and proudly showed off to OH when he came in from work! (I also tried on our walk, and it worked a while, but she goes off even high value treats when there's other interesting smells around, so more work needed there). So this morning I let her out in the garden, but I was wearing my dressing gown and the whistle was upstairs in the pocket of my jeans. Went to call her in - and she stood at the fence staring at me. I called her again - nothing! It suddenly twigged what she was waiting for. I said to OH - can you whistle? He said no. Now I can't usually whistle, but from somewhere I managed to do a very weak sort of three squeaks. Bess jumped round and ran in immediately. So - looks like she'll only come in when we whistle her now! Was not the result I wanted to replace coming when called, to coming when whistled. Mind you, she is clever enough to be having me on!