Hey What is your opinion of breeders choosing pups for you? Personally, I don't like it and would walk away from a breeder who chose my puppy for me. I would want to choose my pup myself, its going to be hopefully living with me for up to 15 years, so I want to choose my dog, not someone else choose for me. If I was looking for a show dog, a breeding dog or a working dog, then I would obviously take the advice of a breeder on which pup out of the litter would do better than the others, but for a pet, I would want to choose my pup myself. I respect that breeders may have pups available only to show homes, so obviously you don't have a choice of those pups if you are looking for a pet, but out of pet quality pups, you should get a choice. Do you think a breeder who lets people choose their pups is a BYB? Would you want a breeder to choose your puppy for you (pet home)?