The behaviours in the title of this thread often come up on the forum, I think. I've seen quite a few on humping- particularly dog-dog humping- as well as dogs that play very rough etc.
Here's an article by Jean Donaldson, who sums these behaviours up excellently:
Dogs In Canada Magazine -- » Oh behave: Love and mounting
The article consults Fixed Action Patterns (FAPs) which are innate behaviours that dogs (and all animals) practise, which help in, most noticeably: fight, flight, feeding and reproduction, known as the 'Four Fs' (take a guess at the fourth

). These are triggered by criteria in the environment.
What's interesting is how domestication has allowed for the incompetence of some of these behaviours to arise, despite the behaviours being innate and pre-programmed:
Quote:
|
Domesticated animals are no longer making a living in the world the same way as their wild forbearers did, so they can afford to drop certain software programs without penalty. A cow without a well-developed flight response is in much less danger than a deer. In some cases, breeding practices have deliberately softened up or greatly raised the triggering threshold for an FAP, such as in the case of Cavalier King Charles Spaniels, which for the most part eschew fighting.
|
Humping is a behaviour that is notoriously deemed as the dreaded 'dominance'- especially when it is performed on a same-sex individual. However, with looking at FAPs, humping can be seen as a innate, hardwired behaviour that a dog engages in when it is triggered by the environment. A large amount of the time, it is during play- when the dog is over-aroused and engages in this behaviour in order to continue the play session but perhaps also in attempt to control the dog's adrenaline rush. Humping can be triggered by noises, sights, interactions and smells and does not mean that your dog is taking the the conscious decision to 'dominate' another dog or person for some mythical ranking system.
Play fighting also pertains to Fixed Action Patterns. Obviously, fighting for food, 'attacking' other animals and running away from predators are not nearly as essential for domestic dogs as they are for wolves, but they nevertheless still exist behaviourally in the dog's brain, despite to a lesser extent. Rough play, biting and chasing can look quite scary at first, especially when you hear dogs trumpeting guttural snarks and demonised growls. But a lot of the time, the dogs are simply loving the experience of playing and are engaged in these innate behaviours.
However, that is not to say that a dog who engages in Fixed Action Patterns are completely sociable. Dogs that hump strange dogs immediately, or constantly dive into rough play can cause a lot of trouble. These dogs are best seen as 'socially inept' and are most probably unsure of how exactly to act around other dogs, and so engage in these behaviours as they are some kind of 'default' routine, hardwired in the dog's mind. Donaldson talks about the consent rule, which is very useful:
Quote:
|
If, on the other hand, you think you might consider allowing her to do it during play, perform a consent test. If you suspect at any time that her partner may not be consenting, pull her off for a moment. Does the mountee grab this opportunity to get away? Does he or she hang out nearby? Or does he or she solicit play from your dog? This consent test works for pinning, wrestling, chasing and other behaviours where there is any doubt about whether both dogs are enjoying the action.
|
So for those that have dogs which perhaps exhibit these behaviours often and all too readily, it is most likely due to an inability to engage in other socially acceptable behaviours. This is what the dog knows. It is not to do with dominance, power-games or usurping others for ranking positions. Just as a human will suddenly babble when in the company of new people, make stupid jokes with a new girl or bite their finger nails, the behaviours are driven by being unable to engage in something else. Teaching dogs to engage in more acceptable behaviours and rewarding for doing so will help them control their emotions much more efficiently.