Of BSL.
“Breed Specific Law is Bad Law - it Simply Doesn't Work” - Peers Speak Out Over Flawed Dangerous Dogs Legislation - The Kennel Club

“Breed Specific Law is Bad Law - it Simply Doesn't Work” - Peers Speak Out Over Flawed Dangerous Dogs Legislation

27-Apr-09

The ‘Dog Control Bill’ tabled by Liberal Democrat Peer Lord Redesdale, received its second reading in the House of Lords on Friday.

The Bill, which could repeal the Dangerous Dogs Act, received support from Conservative and Liberal Democrat Peers on the basis that it is non breed specific and would do more to target irresponsible owners and better protect the public. Lord Tyler (Liberal Democrat) highlighted that the Dangerous Dogs Act is quoted to political students as an example of “the dangers of knee jerk legislation” and added “breed specific law is bad law; it simply doesn’t work”. Earl Cathcart (Conservative) stated that the DDA was “hastily brought in” and that “You wouldn’t arrest a human based on their looks so why dogs?”

The Kennel Club broadly welcomed the second reading of the Bill which if passed, would introduce major changes to current dangerous dogs legislation. These changes include:

* Legislation would no longer be breed specific - it is generally accepted that genetics (breed) plays only a part in the temperament of an individual dog and scientific studies from around the world show that environment and training have a far greater effect.
* More emphasis on the owner, so that instead of banning specific breeds of dog, the dog’s behaviour – as well as its treatment by its owner – would be used to determine if it is a risk to public safety under the Dog Control Bill.
* Attacks on private property would also become a criminal offence.

Following the debate, Lord Redesdale agreed to review various parts of the Bill, including removing a clause which would make it an offence to keep a dog that has injured another dog or animal. The Kennel Club had previously raised concerns that this could theoretically lead to the seizure of any dog which attacked a rat or rabbit for example, and had pushed for the Bill to be amended.

Caroline Kisko, Kennel Club Communications Director, welcomed Friday’s response by the Lords: “The debate which took place in the House of Lords is an extremely welcome one. Current legislation is severely flawed and has failed in its attempts to protect the public or reduce the number of pit bull terriers in the UK.

“The Kennel Club is pleased that Lord Redesdale will now look to amend his Bill at committee stage and we will continue to push for changes on areas of the Bill with which we have concerns.”

I really hope this is the start of something! BSL just isn't fair

Glad to hear this! However, it is only one person speaking out, and with some of the 'bigger issues' out there today, I think dogs are the last thing on the Government's mind i'm not convinced this will really make too much difference, but I do hope it will

__________________

R.I.P Buster - Causing mischief over the bridge, sleep tight soldier

Let's hope so, it's about time something was done

__________________

R.I.P Barney, I had 4 wonderful years with you, Thank you-29/04/06-25/11/09
The dog who saved my life
Proud owner of Maya, the Rescued Alaskan Malamute

http://www.dog-breeds-plus.com
Mine and My husband's Dog breed website

Fingers crossed - X
I hope it the start of the end of poor legislation.

__________________


A dog Possesses Beauty without Vanity,Strength without Insolence, Courage without Ferocity, And all the Virtues of Man without his Vices.

Its not just one person speaking out, its a Bill, at its second reading in the House of Lords... so its going to go its (slow ) way up and we just have to hope that it comes out of it, officially passed by Parliament, with the thrust of it still untainted, and hopefully also some welcome modifications...

Its looking good lets be optimistic!!

When I saw this on the news I thought of you Sallyanne - . I am pleased it is being brought to people's attention again. Let's hope a lot of thought is put into it instead of the knee jerk reactions that usually happen.

im praying its the end of this ridiculous legislation, & those poor innocent dogs who are caught up in it can go back to their homes

__________________
"If the wolf is to survive, the wolf haters must be outnumbered. They must be outshouted, out financed, and out voted. Their narrow and biased attitude must be outweighed by an attitude based on an understanding of natural processes."
L David Mech

We have doomed the Wolf not for what it is, but for what we have deliberately and mistakenly perceived it to be..the mythologized epitome of a savage, ruthless killer..which is, in reality no more than a reflexed images of ourself." -Farley Mowat