Quote:
Originally Posted by Leah84
sorry but i have to completely disagree with that, neutering CAN alter a dogs personality as you`re taking away the production of hormones. i`ve heard of dogs both changing for the better AND worse from being neutered - i actually know of one who became extremely aggressive afterwards but was a well balanced and trained dog beforehand, it took months of working with a behaviorist to get him back to the dog he once was. it`s a bit of a sweeping statement saying it doesn`t change their personality, that may be your opinion and your experience but it isn`t always the case!
|
Well I can only comment on my experience and of the experience of those I know with neutered dogs. Sometimes it is most definitely the worst thing to neuter an already nervous dog because that dog needs all the testosterone he can get just to get through life!
With my neutered male here at the mo, he was a great big goofball before castration, and he's still a great big goofball at 5 1/2 (castrated at 18 months). The castration has taken away his urges in the sexual department (although when my bitch is in season, he has a VERY good nose) but he is just as bouncy and mad as ever!
So my point is that if the dog's personality is outgoing and is hitting a teenage phase, taking the hormones away isn't necessarily the cure-all the vets will tell you - better to go back to square one with training and get the dog through the phase. I'm not saying I'm against castration, I know about dog's urges (and bitches for that matter) but do not agree that whipping off the testicles is always the best option at this age unless the dog is showing aggression or being over-sexualised.
I had a puppy I bred returned to me at 9 months. He is a large breed gundog, and had hit his teenage phase, and was generally an active pup. So the owners on the advice of their vet castrated him at 7 months, thinking it would calm him down - NOPE!! So they called me, and I took him back. It became obvious from the first minute that they weren't meeting the needs of this dog. He had NO idea what he was supposed to do. It didn't take long, with regular walks and my dog/me showing him how to behave - what a beautiful dog, who was robbed of his manhood just because the owners couldn't be bothered to put the time in with him. This pup was no problem AT ALL - he got what he needed and didn't give me a moment's worry while he was here...
The dog will mature in time and calm down anyway - better to put some extra work in and end up with a better trained individual imo. i've also heard that castrating while the dog is displaying negative behaviour will "fix" the dog at that phase.