Well it looks like the dry food company has you all well & truely suckered in ha! 'Smells' that's cos as soon as you open the packaging it starts to degrade. The nice tempting oil they spray on it starts to warm up even when it's put into an air tight box Mmmmmm. Ever wondered why so many cat's have bladder problems?? Bet you even believe it keeps their teeth clean & healthy, imagine it, if the dentist suggested you eat a digestive biscuit to clean your teeth!!!!! Sticky lil stuff aint it. Now I have my hands over my head to be bombarded with Dry kibble lovers.