Hi all, all advice is welcome

I feed my 1yr old cat on Science plan adult and my 20wk old kitten an science Plan kitten as recommended by my vet but I also give them half a pouch of Whiskers each as a treat at night but never realized that Whiskers was of bad quality until I started to read these posts. I went to ASDA today and found these pouches called feline Fayre and picked up a tuna, tuna & salmon and a pilchard one. the ingredients are:

Tuna
tuna red meat(60%),water, gelling agent, soy bean oil,glucose, sucrose, minerals.

• Protein 14.0%
• Oils & fats 2.0%
• Fiber 0.1%
• Ash 3.0%
• Moisture 84.0%
• Vitamin A 22000 iu/kg
• vitamin D3 250 iu/kg
• vitamin E 50 iu/kg

Tuna & Salmon
tuna (57%), salmon(3%),water, gelling agent, soy bean oil,glucose, sucrose, minerals.

• Protein 14.0%
• Oils & fats 2.0%
• Fiber 0.10%
• Ash 3.5%
• Moisture 84.0%
• Vitamin A 22000 iu/kg
• vitamin D3 250 iu/kg
• vitamin E 50 iu/kg

PilchardsFish and fish derivatives (pilchard 60%), water, gelling agent, soy bean oil,glucose, sucrose,various sugars.

• Protein 9.0%
• Oils & fats 1.0%
• Fiber 1.0%
• Ash 3.0%
• Moisture 84.0%
• Vitamin A 22000 iu/kg
• vitamin D3 250 iu/kg
• vitamin E 50 iu/kg

I am hoping that you could tell me if these pouches are better than Whiskers.

Thanks