i did have a little giggle at the whole telling off then cuddles bit lol. The thing is she says she doesonly ceasar training, well its not paying off, weather she is actually training properly as it seems she is quite relaxed about it well all i can say is proper training has to start or she will go round like this forever. Ok i had , i repeat , had noisey yappy dogs, i trained round the clock for three months just to instill into them what was and what wasnt exceptable, i used the ceaser tried and tested ways and it worked but i took them out of the enviroment of where they barked the most which was the back garden , so no garden , just walks, I know only got a small problem with one dog cos we got new neighbours lol and when she sees them next door she barks lol, gonna have to instill the training again i think but it wont take three months again lol. clickers are ok but not everyone has one to hand 24/7 to correct behaviour so it too easy to miss out on telling dog not to do something. good luck and you need to really get the mother in law on board, watch ceaser doing his training together and say hey we can do that , lets have a real good go tomorrow and see how it goes. good luck.