Hi.
I'm pretty much having the same dilemma with my two. I started them on Nature's Menu last year as I wasn't happy with the lack of meat in other brands. They ate it for a while then went off it. I then tried Hi-Life. Same again. I have now gone back to the cheap and nasty junk food from Asda that they were on before, and they hardly eat this now! I have started giving them turkey breast and white fish, 'human food' which I cook myself, and they love it! They also love salmon and tuna, but not the cat variety
I am getting really fed up as I am at my whits end! All I want is a good quality food they will stick to. My little Rossi is losing weight, she has conjunctivis at the mo and is down in the dumps, so they are being fed 'nice' food.
I think I will just buy a high meat content food and stick with it. Thing is, I can't bear the thought of them not eating as they don't like it, although lots of people advise to keep feeding it, they will eat it eventually. Argh!!!

Thank god they still like their dry food!