I used paper with my first puppy Toffee and it took him ages to get fully housetrained
but with Gypsy (she's nearly 12 weeks now) I decided not to use paper at all but to whisk her into the garden whenever I saw her sniffing , after meals and when she first woke up , and in the two weeks we've had her we have only had two accidents
she goes to the front door when she wants out , if its in the night she licks my face to wake me to let her out ... id never train a dog on paper again

__________________