I totally agree that a dog is for life. (or pretty much any pet that forms attachments, to be honest). I also think breeders should be more careful about homing around Christmas. I don't think they shouldn't breed then though, if there are good reasons for doing so.

For some people, Christmas is a good time to get apuppy, as the whole family will be at home to help it settle in. I also think if the puppy is well raised by the breeder, the comings and goings of Christmas shouldn't affect it adversely.

We got Indi just before Christmas. It did mean re-arranging our plans slightly, but that was fine with us. i think all the visitors did her good, she is super-outgoing!