This is the thing I dont think Im being consistent, I think because Im so desperate for this to stop, Im panicking and just either shouting, getting fed up and just doing things out of desperation. I'm more oftern that not saying NO. Everything else Im just not so bothered about so Im more consistent, he's happy in his crate, he's not peeing or pooing in the house (only a few accidents, mainly wee, and this is only because I have a bad back and cant get to him in time, but he's going straight out as soon as he attempts and accident.

I understand he's only playing but Im just finding it hard in the timings as well as the right method. Everyone has an opinion and its having the comon sense to balance between treating him like a dog and treating him with kindness....