Hi Guys

well i took your advice and let the others back in when they have been ,but bob will still not go and will just sit there looking at the door and i can now be out there for up to 2 hrs now and of course by then the others need to go again so out there even longer.

Plus i feel sorry for my other dogs as they are getting no attention off of me when i am out in the garden with just bob and quiet often winston (dad) wants to come back out with me because he is my little shadow.

I have played with him to encorage him to go ,i have ignored him,i have even showed him the treat.
But he will just not go,well tell a lie twice he has been in the last week and i have gave him so much praise and the treat ,but he still does not work it out.

I have now ordered some toilet training spray to see if that will work for him.

The other 2 puppies are doing really well ,i take them out and say go wee wee and with in a very short time they are going.